Stress is counterproductive
October 28th, 2008It’s easy to forget that modern society is a very new aspect of human evolution. Modern Homo Sapiens originated around 200,000 years ago, and the Genus Homo of Homo Sapiens is estimated to be around 2.5 million years old. Mammals themselves first appeared a distant 200 million years ago.
However, until about 10,000 years ago, humans generally lived as hunter-gatherers. The earliest known writing, cuneiform, is only 5,000 years old, and Copernicus didn’t even make the blasphemous proposition that the Earth actually orbited the Sun until a mere 500 years ago. Natural selection has barely even begun to account for the hustle and bustle of modern life, which has accelerated at an unprecedented pace. Simply put, humans are not designed for scrutinizing legal provisions, but for spearing fish and thieving secret squirrel stashes.
Naturally, these 200 million years of mammalian evolution, void of the chaos of modern civilization, have crafted stress as a means of triggering one of two physiological responses when in danger: fight or flight. If you see a lion when digging up plant roots, run! If an unarmed caveman who’s smaller than you wants to ransack your cave, fight! However, if a creditor sends out a collection notice, these options don’t suffice. If you drop your mail and run, someone will steal your identity. If you try to fight the creditor, you get to observe cement’s very slow rate of decay from your jail cell.
Stress is a primitive means of dealing with primitive danger. Its instinctive nature works great for avoiding traditional dangers such as rattlesnakes and vicious, blood-thirsty panda bears, but such dangers just don’t dominate modern life. Our evolution hasn’t caught up to instill instinctive fears of electricity, aspartame, or dice games in shady stairwells.
Stress now, however, is more often than not, a reaction to psychological upsets. This is the counterproductive nature of stress: unpleasant conundrums which require critical reasoning to solve are dealt with on a physiological fight or flight basis. Most of life’s lousy dilemmas require mental problem solving abilities, not fighting or escaping from enemies to protect the food hoard.
When experiencing inevitable stress, which is a part of life now more than ever, try to recognize it as a message that something is amiss. It takes a lot of discipline to suppress rash impulses, but try to figure out the heart of the problem. First try stating the problem, which is often half the answer, then try reasoning through it. Think of stress as a good thing, a message telling you that a predicament is at hand. Then counter the stress with relaxation and critical reasoning.
Whether by personality or experience, highly successful people usually aren’t motivated by stress. That’s not to say the danger of failure isn’t a motivator, but their reason for doing what they do usually isn’t stress itself. A life buried in stress often doesn’t get very far. Warren Buffett, for example, sees making a money as a strategy game. He doesn’t live a lavish lifestyle or bathe in Cristal (but then again, does anyone really know?), but yet he keeps on trying to make more money. But for what end? Perhaps his Bridge addiction is most telling. If evaluating price to earnings ratios made Buffett stressed out and miserable, he might be busy scrapbooking or baking instead.
Stress is old hat for modern society. It leads to shoddy judgment when sound judgment is needed most. The worst part is that stress and fear “occupies a person’s working memory,” draining the brain’s working capacity, which in turn leads to bad judgment when a cool head is needed most.1 The health consequences associated with stress also don’t go without warning: cardiovascular disease, brain shrinkage, and substance abuse. Unfortunately, our predisposed fight and flight reactions haven’t caught up to the pseudo-civilized nature of modern society. When stressed, it’s often probably best to take a step back and rationalize, and then respond in a well-reasoned way. Of course, well-reasoned might mean doing something radical like suggesting the theory of gravity.. just be smart about it!
1. http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSN1736444120070220

